Consolation of Philosophy, The


Consolation of Philosophy, The
(Consolatio Philosophiae)
   by Boethius
(524–526)
   BOETHIUS’s Consolation of Philosophy is a short philosophical tract composed when the author was in prison, awaiting execution for treason by Theodoric the Ostrogoth. The text deals with the basic question of why, in a universe governed by divine providence, innocent people suffer and the wicked go unpunished. Boethius, an orthodox Christian, never alludes to a Christian God or Christian doctrine in his text, choosing instead to try to work out the problem strictly through human reason. The sentiments and teachings of the Consolation, however, proved compatible to medieval Christianity, and the book became one of most popular texts in Europe for 1,000 years. The form Boethius uses in the Consolation is an ancient classical genre called Menippean satire, which consists of alternating sections of prose and poetry. In the Consolation the poems generally either sum up points that Philosophy has argued or give Boethius a chance to reflect upon whatever point has just been made. In effect the poems also enable the reader to ponder and digest the rather dense prose arguments. Structurally, the text is a dialogue between Philosophy and the persona Boethius has created of himself. As such, it is not unlike a Platonic dialogue, with Philosophy taking the part of Socrates and Boethius in the position of the character whom the philosopher draws out in order to instruct. In fact, the text of the Consolation owes a great deal to Plato—whose work Boethius knew well—though it also draws significantly from Aristotle, as well as from the Stoics, Plotinus, Cicero, and St. AUGUSTINE.
   The Consolation opens with the character Boethius in his prison cell, lamenting his downfall. Lady Philosophy enters and, seeking to cure him, begins questioning him to find the nature of his mental distress.He complains to her that God’s providence seems to govern all things except the affairs of human beings. She responds that he is the cause of his own misery, having strayed too far from her wisdom, his true country. In Book II Philosophy reminds Boethius that he should not complain about Fortune’s treatment of him, since it is her nature to be fickle. Nothing on earth actually belongs to us, Philosophy argues, and therefore Fortune can take nothing that is truly ours. Wealth, power, honor, fame—all of these are transient. Bad fortune, in fact, is advantageous, since it teaches us not to depend on the things of this world and shows us who our true friends are.
   It is the nature of all human beings to seek the Highest Good (i.e., God), Philosophy continues in Book III, and true happiness lies in attaining what we truly seek. Those things in the power of Fortune are partial goods, and cannot bring true happiness. But Boethius stresses the question, in Book IV, of why good people suffer and why evil goes unpunished. Philosophy’s answer is that the wicked are weak and unhappy, since true happiness lies in seeking the Good, and power is defined as attaining what one seeks. The Good, therefore, are happy, since they have what they desire. Further, what seems unjust from our earthly perspective can be seen as justice from the eternal perspective of divine providence. In his fifth book Boethius addresses chance, free will, and providence. Boethius cannot reconcile human free will with God’s foreknowledge. Philosophy explains that God sees all from eternity—defined as timelessness rather than endless time. From the eternal view, past, present, and future are witnessed as a single instant. The temporal vantage point sees things as changing, sees moments as occurring one after another. Since God sees all things as we see the present, he does not cause all things—the actions of human free will are seen but not caused by him.
   Boethius was executed in prison, shortly after he completed his text of the Consolation, and the work was little known in the decades immediately following. However, it became hugely popular in the succeeding centuries. A large number of Latin manuscripts and commentaries by scholars like William of Conches, Nicholas TRIVET, and Pierre d’Ailly were made. In addition the text was one of the first Latin texts to be translated into vernacular European languages. King ALFRED THE GREAT made a translation into OLD ENGLISH, believing it to be, after the Bible, the one book he thought his people should read. Translations were also made into German, Dutch, and Italian. Later JEAN DE MEUN translated it into French, and Maximus Planudes into Greek. In the 14th century Geoffrey CHAUCER translated it into MIDDLE ENGLISH, and the Consolation proved to be a significant influence on his subsequent works, in particular The KNIGHT’S TALE and TROILUS AND CRISEYDE. Through the prestige of its being perhaps the last document of classical antiquity passed on to western Europe, as well as its sheer popularity evidenced by the plethora of manuscripts, commentaries and translations, the Consolation of Philosophy exerted a profound influence on medieval European literature, and, ultimately, on the entire Western literary tradition.
   Bibliography
   ■ Boethius. The Consolation of Philosophy. Translated by P. G.Walsh. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.
   ■ Chadwick, Henry. Boethius: The Consolations of Music, Logic, Theology and Philosophy Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1981.
   ■ Gibson,Margaret, ed. Boethius: His Life, Thought, and Influence. Oxford: Blackwell, 1981.
   ■ Marenbon, John. Boethius. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003.
   ■ Reiss, Edmund. Boethius. Boston: Twayne Publishers, 1982.
   ■ O’Daly, Gerard. The Poetry of Boethius. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1991.

Encyclopedia of medieval literature. 2013.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Consolation of Philosophy, The — (Latin, De Consolatione Philosophiae), a philosophical work (A.D. 523?) by Boethius. * * * …   Universalium

  • Consolation of Philosophy, The — (Latin, De Consolatione Philosophiae), a philosophical work (A.D. 523?) by Boethius …   Useful english dictionary

  • Consolation of Philosophy — For the book by Alain de Botton published in 2000, see The Consolations of Philosophy. This early printed book has many hand painted illustrations depicting Lady Philosophy and scenes of daily life in fifteenth century Ghent (1485) Consolation of …   Wikipedia

  • Philosophy and its background in the early medieval West — Rosamond McKitterick and John Marenbon ‘Libraries, schools and the dissemination of texts’ is by Rosamond McKitterick; the ‘Introduction’ and ‘Philosophical themes’ are by John Marenbon. INTRODUCTION The period from 800 to 1100 is even more… …   History of philosophy

  • The Consolations of Philosophy — (ISBN 0 140 27661 0) is a nonfiction book by Alain de Botton. First published by Hamish Hamilton in 2000, subsequent publications (2001 onwards) have been by Penguin Books.The title of the book is a reference to Boethius s magnum opus Consolation …   Wikipedia

  • The Vatican —     The Vatican     † Catholic Encyclopedia ► The Vatican     This subject will be treated under the following heads:     I. Introduction; II. Architectural History of the Vatican Palace; III. Description of the Palace; IV. Description of the… …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • The Canterbury Tales — is a collection of stories written by Geoffrey Chaucer in the 14th century (two of them in prose, the rest in verse). The tales, some of which are originals and others not, are contained inside a frame tale and told by a collection of pilgrims on …   Wikipedia

  • The Kingis Quair — is a fifteenth century poem attributed to James I of Scotland. It is semi autobiographical in nature, describing the King s capture by the English in 1406 on his way to France and his subsequent imprisonment by Henry IV of England and his… …   Wikipedia

  • The Gaze of Orpheus — is derived from the antiquarian Greek myth of Orpheus and Eurydice. Following his descent into the Underworld Orpheus disobeys Hades’ and Persephone’s condition for release of his wife Eurydice. To you this tale refers,Who seek to lead your… …   Wikipedia

  • philosophy, Western — Introduction       history of Western philosophy from its development among the ancient Greeks to the present.       This article has three basic purposes: (1) to provide an overview of the history of philosophy in the West, (2) to relate… …   Universalium


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.